Plastic vs metal dog food containers

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Disclosure

Short answer: plastic bins are lighter, often cheaper, and several come with an airtight claim and wheels. Metal cans split into two very different products: a stainless kitchen can whose food still sits in a plastic bucket (simplehuman), and a galvanized utility can that Behrens calls rodent proof and specifies for dry storage only. Either way, the bag inside the container is what Hill's and the FDA recommend.

One of each

Specs from the makers, checked 18 Nov 2026.

Plastic, stainless and galvanized — what the makers state

Every cell below is something a manufacturer or Hill's has published, or is marked "not published" or "not claimed." We do not have lab tests of odor, chew resistance or seal performance.

Plastic (HDPE or other food-contact plastic)Stainless can with inner bucketGalvanized steel
Examples hereVittles Vault Outback (HDPE, food-grade; complies with FDA food-contact rules, per the maker). IRIS WeatherPro (BPA-free plastic). Van Ness (BPA-free, USFDA food-contact approved). Buddeez and OXO (material not published as a resin name)simplehuman Medium (25–29 lb) and X-Large (36–44 lb): stainless steel can, removable BPA-free plastic inner bucketBehrens 6110 10 gal locking-lid can, made in the USA
Airtight claimVittles Vault (Gamma Seal lid with double gaskets), IRIS (airtight seals / airtight lid) and OXO (push-button POP lid): yes. Van Ness: not claimed — the Fresh-Tite seal is said to limit moisture and pests, without the word airtight. Buddeez: not publishedYes — silicone gasket and a lock-tight handle, per simplehumanNot claimed. Behrens describes the can as rodent proof and weather resistant, not airtight
Rodent claimNoneNone. The steel is the shell; the food is in the plastic bucket"Rodent proof" (Behrens). The pet catalog says the locking lid stays on when the can is tipped over or attacked by an animal, and that it keeps rodents out
Odor and oilsVittles Vault: over time, oils from pet food absorb into the plastic and can make food rancid — wash and dry regularly. Hill's packaging engineers found that a variety of plastic containers may impart an odor and taste to dry pet foodThe food touches the plastic bucket, not the steel. The bucket lifts out to wash. simplehuman does not publish an oil-absorption noteHill's says storage in clean metal containers is acceptable. Behrens specifies dry storage only
WheelsVan Ness: four removable in-line wheels. IRIS 58 lb: attachable casters. Vittles Vault, IRIS 15 qt, Buddeez, OXO: noBuilt-in rear wheels (simplehuman; dimensions and wheels from a Costco retailer listing)No
Where the maker says to use itVittles Vault: indoor or covered outdoor use; climate-controlled storage recommended. Others: not published as an indoor/outdoor ratingNot published as an outdoor can; the shape is a slim kitchen can (10.4 in wide)Dry storage only; also described as weather resistant
WarrantyNot published on the plastic models we list10 years (simplehuman)Not published

Hill's: plastic containers may impart odor and taste to food; clean metal containers are acceptable; keep the food in its bag inside the container (Hill's Pet Nutrition). FDA: whatever you use should be clean, dry and have a snug lid; prefer putting the whole bag into the container rather than pouring (FDA). Royal Canin's US FAQ also allows a dry, airtight plastic or steel container, with the original bag kept inside (Royal Canin US).

How to read the metal column

"Metal" is not one product. simplehuman is the can you park in a kitchen: airtight by claim, a 10-year warranty, a magnetic scoop, rear wheels, and a plastic bucket you lift out to wash. It is not sold as rodent proof. Behrens is the can you use where mice have already chewed a bag: galvanized steel, a locking lid, about 32 lb of medium kibble per the maker, no airtight claim, no wheels, dry storage only. Choosing "metal" in the finder will surface both; the pest and place questions are what separate them. More detail is on the metal containers page.

If odor is the reason you are leaving plastic, keeping the food in its original bag — which Hill's says provides a fat barrier — does more than switching materials and then pouring kibble into a bare bucket. That is also why Vittles Vault's wash-regularly warning matters even if you like the Gamma Seal lid. Cleaning by material is in how to clean the container.

Decision tree

  1. Mice or rats where you store the food? Yes → galvanized steel whose maker claims rodent protection (Behrens 6110), kept somewhere dry and off the floor. See keeping ants and mice out.
  2. No → Ants or humidity? Yes → a container whose maker claims airtight (airtight list), plastic or stainless.
  3. No → Want it to look at home in a kitchen, with a scoop and a slim footprint? Stainless (simplehuman). Otherwise a plastic bin is lighter and usually the budget option — compared on the budget page.

Two plastic vault shapes — a tall 50 lb Outback versus a shorter stackable 40 lb bin — are compared in Vittles Vault Outback vs Stackable.

FAQ

Is a metal dog food container better than plastic?
It depends on the job. Behrens calls its galvanized can rodent proof; none of the plastic bins we list makes that claim. Hill's says clean metal containers are acceptable and that some plastic containers may impart an odor and taste. For ants and humidity, look at whether the maker claims an airtight seal — several plastic bins and both simplehuman steel cans do; the Behrens can does not.
Does stainless steel mean the food never touches plastic?
Not on the simplehuman cans we list. The outer can is stainless steel; the food sits in a removable BPA-free plastic inner bucket. That bucket is what you wash.

Specs verified: November 2026 · Updated 2026-11-18 · How we research